David Gold Shana Tova I think the reason the Rabbi thought of me as someone…
Longpath, Rosh HaShanah Day 2
Emily SHapiro
Rosh HaShanah seems like a perfect time to be thinking about time. It’s a new beginning and yet, also, a repetition. Rosh HaShanah comes round again and again and again, always followed by Yom Kippur ten days later, Sukkot, Simchat
Torah…and we launch into the rest of the year.
This year, following last Simchat Torah, which was October 7, has felt qualitatively different from other years. My own sense of who I am in this world has been unmoored in a way that is very disconcerting. And yet, if I look at what has changed it is also an example of “the more things change, the more they stay the
same.” I always assumed things would keep getting better. It seemed self-evident that, in the often quoted words of the
Reverend Martin Luther King Jr., the arc of history bends toward justice. Now I find that I am not so sure.
Maybe I was making a mistake all along about the shape of history. Is it an arc that bends? An arc is a kind of line. It has a
beginning and an end, which implies change in a direction.
In just a couple of weeks we celebrate Sukkot with its linear narrative of the journey through the desert. Most of the year, we
make our challah out of three or more strands braided together lengthwise. But on Rosh haShanah, we make a round challah. One way this tradition is understood is that it represents the circularity of time as the seasons continue, we come back to the beginning of the Torah, and continue the ongoing repetition of the holiday cycle.
The Jewish calendar seems to me to give—in stereotypical Jewish fashion—a “both and” answer rather than an “either or”
answer to the question of whether time is linear or circular. We exist in nature, on a planet that turns, with seasons that go round and round. And we exist in history, which appears as a linear narrative. This year I’m not even sure whether history really is linear. My great grandparents probably did not expect things to be moving in a line of progress. Maybe history is just a lot of stuff going round and round. In this case, I definitely need the cycle of holidays to give me some sense of order, points around which to orient myself.
Which brings me to the question Rabbi Lauren posed. Or rather, the question with which my contrarian mind responded to Rabbi Lauren’s prompt.
How is it best to orient myself in time? Is it best to take the long path, keeping our eyes far ahead of us and our thoughts on what lies around the bend, beyond what we can see? Or are we better off being fully present in the current moment, since we can’t change the past or know the future? I have found consolation in both views.
There is a tree in the little park near my home with a bench under it where I like to sit and look up at the sky and the leaves, feel the sun or the wind, the warmth or the chill. Even five minutes in that spot can ground me, restore me to feeling present in myself. There was a park in Jerusalem, when I lived there in my 20’s and had not yet discovered antidepressants, that supported me through difficult days. I’m a city kid, but a good city has spots where it’s possible to sit and watch the breeze in the trees. In those moments, in those places, it is best for me to be aware of myself in each second, each infinitesimally small bit of time in which all there is is my senses experiencing my immediate environment. In those moments there is no line, just a single point in time.
Other times, I need the long view, which stretches well beyond me. I’ve gotten better at the long path as I get older, and it’s a
good thing, too, since the span of my own lifetime no longer seems infinite. Long, G-d willing, but not infinite. Sometimes this
frightens me. But I can see beyond myself. I know I will live on in my children and in everyone whose life I have touched. I
discovered this when my dad died, z”l. This allows me to feel a part of infinity.
When the place we are in in history and politics feels terrifying, I find it comforting to remember that we actually have no idea what will happen—I believe it’s at least as likely that something good will happen as something bad (there is an example of my dad living on in me!). Whatever one believes about the odds, the fact is, we don’t know that the things we fear will happen. Is that the long view, keeping in mind that the future is much longer than we can know or take responsibility for? Or is it a focus on the present, since the present is all we can know?
Too much focus on the future can sometimes create anxiety. This is why first aid for a panic attack involves refocusing the person’s attention on where they are right now: Can you name five objects you can see? Four sounds you can hear? Three textures you can feel? Two smells you can smell? One taste you can taste? A tween client of mine called her mother from day camp last summer in a panic attack. Her mother intuitively and brilliantly engaged the child in a game of I-spy over the phone: Tell me what you can see that is red? Blue? Yellow? Round? Square? Until the young person was able to breathe calmly and re-regulate.
Too much focus on the future can create anxiety. But sometimes we can get stuck in an unpleasant present, and the ability to look forward even to the near future can sustain us. I recently received an email from an older gentleman in my practice that read, “it’s 2:45 AM, I can’t sleep and I’m feeling very down. But experience tells me one should never give too much weight to middle of the night moods as they generally pass by morning”. A teenager I know went to sleepaway camp this summer for the first time. Their therapist—not me, but I have adopted this—passed on wisdom she learned from her own mother: The first three days and nights in a new place don’t count. Only after that can you tell how you will feel there. In other words, if you feel homesick or out of place, look beyond that feeling in that moment, don’t let your mind fool you into believing that feeling is all there is.
The greatest joys and pleasures are to be found in moments when we are fully present, in body, mind and soul, with our outwardly focused senses and our inner senses, thoughts and feelings. But also, who would want to give up the excitement of anticipation of something good we are expecting?
It seems to me that in our relationship to time, as in so many realms, we live best if we can be flexible. We suffer when we are stuck in any one position. The crazy ability humans have to choose where on our mental timelines to place our attention is a beautiful thing.
I think time is both linear and circular, even though that seems logically impossible. And I know that sometimes it is best for me to take a long view, sometimes the shortest view possible, and at other times to focus somewhere in between. Where we focus our attention is one of the relatively few things over which we have agency. My hope for myself, and my wish for everyone, is that we find the optimal focus points for each moment in our lives.
Shanah Tovah.
